Look, I did not see this coming. I do not know if anyone saw this coming! But after reading 100's of comments and considering each one, I have come to my own conclusion and it is this; the Bombers are correct to move on from their head coach Mike O'Shea.

The Past
Mike O'Shea is the Bombers' most winningest coach with 126 wins and 86 losses. That is more wins than Bud Grant put up with the Bombers and Bud has a statue outside of the Winnipeg Blue Bombers' stadium.

Mike O'Shea also took an abysmal team turning it around and won the Grey Cup in 2019, and 2021 (there was no season in 2020). After that, he took Winnipeg to the Grey Cup in 2022, 2023, and 2024. In 2025 and 2026 the Bombers ended up 4th in the West and crossing over both years to be in the playoffs.

So What Gives?
That is not a terrible job, is it? Does that merit a coach getting fired? Many would argue that such output should allow O'Shea to stay as head coach for the Bombers. But not so fast.

You are not going to get much out of Bombers CEO and President, Wade Miller. He has tremendous respect for Mike O'Shea, and so we are going to have to speculate a bit.

Here is what Wade Miller did say,

"Mike's record speaks for itself. Nobody will ever take that away from him," said Miller in a conversation with bluebombers.com this morning. "But my job is to look forward, not back, and after a full evaluation of this season and where we've been headed the last few seasons, I feel like a change gives us the best chance to win a championship."

"I won't break down a 12-year coaching career in sound bites... Mike deserves better than that," he said. "Like I said, my evaluation looked at the season and the direction of the organization over the last few years. Taken together I felt like we needed a new voice to give us the best chance to continue our standard."

Given O'Shea's track record and the fact the team has qualified for the division final in seven of the last eight years, Miller was asked if the safe play might have been to run it back with the same crew in 2027.

"That may have been the safe play but in the role I'm in, my job is not to play safe," he said. "It's to play to win and to get us to the next championship.

"Just looking at the last couple of years and where we're headed, that just didn't feel like that would have been the right situation. As a head coach you end up taking the heat for everything that goes on for your assistants, your players and that sometimes is the unfortunate part of being a head coach."

Reading Between The Lines

"But my job is to look forward, not back, and after a full evaluation of this season and where we've been headed the last few seasons,

The trajectory of the Bombers has not been great for the last couple of years. Combine that with some poor decision making heading into this season and in some previous seasons and that might have part to do with it.

Issues Picking Offensive Coordinators

What do I mean by that? Picking Tommy Condell to replace Jason Hogan as the Bombers' Offensive Coordinator. I do not really care how much Zach Collaros thinks Condell is a great OC. Condell consistently mismanaged the use of the best running back in the CFL (both situationally and in whole game plans), Brady Oliveira...after Hogan had done the same thing previously. Mike O'Shea needs to beheld accountable for that choice of those 2 OCs.

In 2024 we have Buck Pierce as the offensive coordinator who does not run the ball in the Grey Cup even after Collaros came back with a very injured finger.

Exit Buck Pierce.

Enter Jason Hogan.

In the 2025 season I called a lot of decisions 'Hogan Headscratchers."

Exit Jason Hogan.

Enter Tommy Condell.

Tommy Condell has had a long career...but not a great career. Just look at his Wikipedia page.

Furthermore, in 2024 and 2025 Condell was with Ottawa as their offensive coordinator. In 2024 Ottawa finished 3rd in the East with a record of 9-8-1. And in 2025 Ottawa finished with a record of 4-14. How Mike O'Shea hired Condell never made sense to me.

Taken together I felt like we needed a new voice to give us the best chance to continue our standard."

I do not think that Wade Miller is talking about the boring tell nothing interviews.

Earlier this year I wrote this No More Talk It's Time To Deliver!

I criticized the Bombers in 2025 and in 2026 that they maybe did not know what their problem was. All they would talk about was working harder. I called that out a lot! Working harder is not always the solution...and maybe Mike O'Shea did not see that.

Or how about the voice that said, "I wanted to give them a chance to be great." That was what Mike O'Shea said when he put Zach Collaros back into the Grey Cup in Vancouver after Collaros seriously injured his hand.

It is also what Mike O'Shea said about Bighill and Schoen who should have sat out a Grey Cup.

Comparables
Do you remember what Calgary did after their Grey Cup runs? They kept their head coach. How has that worked for them?

In 2025 they were in 3rd place in the West. In 2024, 5th place in the West. 2023, 3rd place in the West. 2022, 2nd place in the west. 2021, 3rd place in the West. 2019, 2nd in the West - and not appearing in any Grey Cups those years.

From 2012 - 2018 Calgary was in 5 Grey Cups, and they won 2 of them.

From 2019 - 2024 Winnipeg was in 5 Grey Cups...and they won 2 of them.

So while Calgary did not do poorly since 2018, they have not been in any other Grey Cups since. The Bombers could follow Calgary's path or they could forge their own way.

76cfad56a421 OShea Record

And speaking about Calgary, when I was their for the Grey Cup this year (before the game started) many Calgary fans were telling me that they wanted to have Mark Kilam as their head coach. They thought that Calgary should have moved on from their current head coach.

Final Thoughts
Do not get me wrong, I am not celebrating this move by the Bombers. Nor do I know if this move will change around the fortunes of the Bombers in the short term.

What I do know is this, Mike O'Shea helped turn this franchise around to be very competitive for many years. He deserves all the credit in the world, there should be a statue of him outside the stadium, he should go in the Bombers' Ring of Honour, and he should go into the CFL Hall of Fame! Full stop. No question about it!!

But two things can be true at the same time.

I can also see reasons why Wade Miller believed that this was the right decision at this time, even after O'Shea signing a three year contract extension and still having two years left on it (more about that in an upcoming article).

I am sure that there is going to be more changes to the Bombers' staff and players as a result of that. For the most part, and without knowing what those changes are I am ok with the notion of that.

In my estimation, the Bombers get one chance to get this right, or mostly right.

Because if this does not work out for the most part then there may be another big change coming and that would be at the President and CEO level. But I believe that Wade Miller knows what he is doing.

Wade even says so!

What do you think? Let me know wherever you are reading this.

Catch all my articles here!